Showing posts with label economics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label economics. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 2, 2026

The Business: The Licensing Lifeline Just Got Cut

On Friday last week, the Pundit dropped the following.

The Pundit gets what the issue is.

This is not a question of "You got Skiffy in my Fantasy!" because that's been part of the game since before its official publication in 1974, made brick-to-face obvious with the crossover rules for Gamma World and Boot Hill in AD&D1e.

No, the issue is Brand Collaborations. This means that Wizards of the Coast are pursuing the Fortnite model, which is where there are license deals made to allow for officially-licensed adaptations for The Only Game That Matters in Current Edition, and as we now see that's going to be fed directly into D&D Beyond where it will remains there as an exclusive offering to draw in new users and retain existing one- further reinforcing platform lock-in, weaponizing the Network Effect to cut off the acquisition of customers to all of the Temu Tabletop tinkerers bottom-feeding off of The Only Game (And Publisher) That Matters.

This will work because it already has for Magic: The Gathering.

This also will cut off license opportunities for everyone else, because WOTC will have the money and the time to suck up any and all such Brand License opportunities going forward and thus deny one of the lifelines that many Temu Tabletop publishers used to keep their operations going heretofore. WOTC is not a high risk proposition for a Brand; even Palladium and Paizo are now, and they're the perenial also-rans. As it is for other Big Corpos, so it will be for everyone else- such as the Burroughs, Howard, and Vance Estates.

You won't be able to court a dormant, but attractive, brand to go with your Temu Tabletop product going forward- not when WOTC is able to pay more, reliably, to a far larger target audience and thus open the door to yet further brand collaboration deals.

If WOTC (and Hasbros) has the sense that God gave a diseased donkey suffering from syphillis and dying of AIDS, they will make it clear that they are the only Tabletop party in town so they should just ghost everyone else. That's it for the PDF Merchants; you can only reskin B/X so many ways, the customer pickup pool from WOTC's castoffs is drying up, and they have neither the skill nor the will to do what it takes to compete and win. The Dying Time is here for them.

If you think this is not an issue on the commercial side, you STILL do not comprehend Network Effects. Pundit is wrong about the lock-in being a bad move because that has already proven itself to be a success. C-Suite is very happy with this; most players now use Beyond exclusively, disdaining print media entirely, precisely because being in the cloud allows for users to log in and play anywhere that supports the client. The shift to being Vidya is already halfway there, and the profits prove it.

Commercial Tabletop is over for everyone but WOTC. What remains is the lagtime between Cause and Effect. It may take a few years, but it's coming all the same. Only the Clubhouse survives.

Monday, May 11, 2026

The Business: WOTC Drones Justify Their Own Extinction

Last Wednesday, Pat cut the following video.

First: This is really about 100 Arena devs vs. Hasbro, not D&D.

Second: LOL.

These wankers have no leverage. Hasbro C-Suite will take this action as justification for liquidating these people, outsourcing/H-1Bing/AI replacing their positions, and then a review will see if the corporate structure needs to be shifted around to secure assets against any future liability threats.

What these people do not comprehend is that they are Hired Guns in positions where they are disposable, expendable, and fungible cogs in a machine. This will result in Hasbro accelerating their plans.

When--not if--this is done, there will be the usual wave of performative outrage before Network Effects do their thing and shut them up because they cannot endure the friction of not being in the scene where it is easiest to play. They will bloviate, and they go right back to giving Hasbro money to continue being viable in competitive play.

Don't think the D&D side of WOTC isn't aware of this. They are.

Hasbro is well aware of the liabilities in WOTC's offices and want to remove them. Some already got punted; the rest will go once the business model revision to rely on bot-generated content and art (and cheap labor otherwise) is complete and--as has been the case for 50 years--those self-possessed poseurs who think they matter will find out fast that all they can do is grift on Kickstarter until that goodwill runs dry.

And, quite frankly, fuck all of them.

The Real Game and thus the Real Hobby, being non-commercial, continues on without any of them unimpeded.

Monday, May 4, 2026

The Business: Once Again, Gaben Does Nothing And Wins

My Vidya brothers, I feel you, and I join you in praising Gaben.

You should take note of this and use it for your benefit.

With Sony, Nintendo, and Microsoft all shooting themselves in the foot you had better believe that Steam giving you the tools to clearly see if your rig can run it is yet another customer-friendly element that everyone else somehow fails to understand or care about.

Want something that's going to work? Have your rig be at least as good as a Steam Deck, then look for Deck OK labelling. Later on Steam Machine labelling will work. Only buy what gets the Green Check.

Or buy from GOG. Those games are so old that you can run it on Grandma's email checker.

This is another place where Indies and AA are rooking AAA across the board; design for the low-end specs of your target audience. This is why World of Warcraft worked- you could run it on the basic bitch machines of the day and do fine, as I know from personal experience.

Saturday, April 11, 2026

The Culture: The Soup Aisle Sucked Vs. Boardgames Too

Boardgame alternatives to the Cargo Cult have also been around for decades and were also a better option.




Same thing: play when I want, how I want, for as long as I want with no ongoing commitments. No bullshit rules fuckery.

This isn't as good a value proposition as the Vidya comparison, but it is still far superior for fulfilling the Cargo Cult Game paradigm of play than what they insist Tabletop has to be about.

Oh, and it's cheaper overall because edition changes are few (if ever) and definitely far between. I can also include Talisman, Advanced Heroquest, Runequest and a lot more than that- and if Sword World does well enough in translation there may be PDFs made available of those Japanese boardgame counterparts also.

Tabletop is not boardgaming or cardgaming. It is not Vidya. It is something separate, distinct, and apart from all of them- which means it is not as the Cargo Cult insists it is either.

It's Braunstein, and that demands something very different- and very human.

Tuesday, April 7, 2026

The Business: They Are Lying About Their Bot Usage

I told you that the answer to AI freakouts would be people flat-out lying about using it.

Wizards of the Coast already does this, nakedly and openly. Revealed Preferences show that NORMIES DO NOT CARE.

You can take all the polls where they say all the Approved Opinions, but when it comes time to buy shit they (a) reveal that they can't tell and (b) reveal that they don't care. Why? For the same reasons that most people don't buy hand-made knives or clothes: the price is way too high for what you get.

The reality is this: when the moneybags see that it's 10x cheaper, but just as good or better, to do it with bots than men the bots get deployed EVERY SINGLE TIME.

Hell, they get deployed when it's only half as good when it's 10x cheaper.

Yes, this does mean publishing is going to change too; the moneybags will gladly sack human authors for House Names attached to bot-generated genre content template output, and now that the tech exists you can even interview them.

At 21:00 you see the interview segment; neither of them are in the depicted space- both of them are remoting into it via hologram tech over the Internet.

You had better believe that they can just make an overlay for a House Name and use it for interviews, and it's going to be cheap and easy to do very soon.

You want to interview Amelia, the meme girl representing UK Remigration? You will be able to before the end of the year; for now, this means someone else (using voice-changing software and livestream overlay technology, both quite mature now) will be able to perform the role. Not long from now, a model trained up to be her on command will be able to do that in real time on the fly.

You want to smear your enemies? Going to be very easy to do now.

You want to churn out plenty of novels in short order? Nevermind Claude; what matters is that you can automate the entire process, including several rounds of "remove AI-isms", including making the cover and formatting for ebook and print for upload to Amazon/B&N/Lulu/etc. while you're off doing other things. People are already making bank doing this; you know who you are.

So no, don't think you can do jack shit about widespread AI adoption and implementation. The ones with the power want this to happen, so it happens and it happens because they benefit from having it. No matter what you say, all they care about is what you do; if they can lie to you to get you to do what they want, they will and they've already justified doing so to themselves so no amount of moral scolding means shit to them. The ability to make them always exceeds the capacity to detect them.

Which means that, contra the hopes of some, the days of bot-generated books and games is far from over.

Sunday, April 5, 2026

The Culture: The Wane Of The Modern Audience

This is (slowly) coming to an end.

With the Trump Administration gutting the funding behind Blackrock's ESG bullshit, this is now in retreat- retreat, not yet surrender.

Surrender is coming so long as the pressure keep ramping up and no backstopping of funding appears; right now that is guaranteed, but a fuckup can change that on a dime. As it is, however, we are looking at this being dead and gone in about the time it took to bloom and flourish- a decade.

The reason? The Death Cult is always subserviant to the Mammon Mob, so when Line Does Not Go Up the Mob gets anxious and when it goes down and keeps falling they get mad- and blame the Death Cult (rightly) for it. As the Mob has the superior position (i.e. control over the money that makes it all possible), the Mob gets its way sooner or later and the Cult gets punted to the ditch.

The problem is people with the inability to get beyond instant gratification. This doesn't turn on a dime- not in film, not in TV, not in Vidya, not in Tabletop, nothing.

In addition to sandbagging by Stay Behinds within an organization, you have the ordinary issue of there being a long lead time for any major corporate media production. Films typically are three years, Vidya is three to five, OldPub is at least a year and often more, and Tabletop is at least as bad. It's going to take time for the cleanup to make itself manifest.

That means you're going to seek plenty of suck for the near term. The signs will begin showing up in no less than a year from now.

This also means that it's going to be uneven; some organizations will turn around faster than others, with the primary determinant being the ratio of Mobster to Cultist within an organization as the Mobster dominance will prompt faster turnarounds.

All said, remember that the Mammon Mob is not your friend; they serve a different demon, but they still serve a demon. All this means is that the Death Cult funnel from the Pop Cult gets cut off in favor of retrenching and doubling-down on the Pop Cult idolatry- they want full-tilt Idol Culture Give All Your Money In Devotion To Something That Can't Love You levels of false religion.

Monday, March 23, 2026

The Business: Seattle Pulls A Bait-And-Switch

GaryCon went down over the weekend. There was some Wizards of the Coast-related announcements.

Wizards of the Coast's D&D Design Team made an appearance at Gary Con XVIII and discussed the future of the brand at a press conference on March 19, 2026. Big news came out at this press conference, which was led by Gary Con founder Luke Gygax (see “ICv2 Interview”) and the new head of the D&D franchise Dan Ayoub, starting with the announcement that Luke Gygax will be collaborating with D&D design team on upcoming projects. Gygax specifically noted that he will be lending his expertise on the Greyhawk setting to future projects, and mentioned a possible Melf's Guide to Greyhawk book coming down the road.

“I grew up playing in Greyhawk,” said Gygax. “The names on the Greyhawk map are named after not only my family, but my friends and relatives. It is a place where I experienced all those adventures as Otis, the Ranger... the places we visited in those early campaigns are all seminal memories for me.”

Ayoub discussed his passion for the D&D brand at length, and acknowledged that he is aware of how D&D design may have gravitated away from fan expectations in the last several years. He addressed the gap in new release information that occurred at the end of 2025 into February 2026, which was primarily due to team transition, and limitations on the team's ability to block releases due to the creation of new content. Ayoub also committed to an annual unveiling of the next year's D&D lineup at Gen Con, starting in 2026 (for the 2027 lineup).

Ayoub also addressed plans for the new Season model for D&D (see “'D&D' Roadmap“), which span roughly three to five months depending on the product release. Ayoub is an advocate of the module format, so aside from the banner releases announced for each Season, there will also be modules on the way.

For retailers, Ayoub reaffirmed the company's dedication to publishing print copies of D&D books. He also reaffirmed the D&D brand's commitment to supporting retailers:

“(The hobby channel) is the beating soul of D&D,” said Ayoub. “I think it is something we've lost sight of a little bit. We've started sharing plans with retailers our plans to support retail...part of the plan behind Seasons was to help support retail.”

I wouldn't get your hopes up.

The Pundit continues.

Which means it's not really part of the Brand. The target audience--Normies, Casuals, Tourists--will not engage with it, especially if this is a print-primary product when Wizards of the Coast have already pivoted to being digital-primary and root the business on Beyond and its service-based model.

The Soup Aisle still thinks that print is going to be primary, that retail matters, and that their siloed cult cells in their basement playing Calvinball is the hobby. Like it or not, WOTC's C-Suite is correct to see that going digital-primary is the smart play because it removes the friction that's been a Known Issue for decades. Beyond is now the root of the business because it is superior in recruiting, training, and retaining players from those three demographics; they pay, they pay early, and they pay often with little difficulty because C-Suite's making the game resemble what they're already familiar with in competing media.

Tabletop, as a business, is driven by Network Effects. That means control over friction. Normies (et. al.) treat friction as failure, so they always go with the least-frictive option; this is why they accept Beyond and other digital formats over what the Cargo Cult demands is still the way to go- even when the data says otherwise.

WOTC isn't stupid or wrong to go digital-primary when all of their competition--Vidya--is already there. We already have online play via Discord as normal; using Beyond is just a fait accompli once you've made that shift for Normies.

This is the pressure from above crushing the Cargo Cult. The Clubhouse is the pressure from below. The collapse is in process for Conventional Play, and anyone thinking that this changes a damned thing is maining Copium straight into their veins like a junky. Either way, the Cargo Cult is on borrowed time and is counting down to extinction; what will remain is WOTC's Walled Garden and the Clubhouse- and the Soup Aisle will have nothing.

Sunday, March 15, 2026

The Business: WOTC's Digital Primary Pivot Confirmed

The Pundit reported early last week confirmation on what I've suspected is the play out of Wizards of the Coast.

WOTC is going Digital Primary. Beyond is the primary outlet for The Only Game That Matters going forward; print is now depreciated and no longer considered important.

This is part of the larger shift to D&D (and Magic) as Lifestyle Brands.

As I said would be the case many times over the last year and change, WOTC knows that their Network Effect is so dominant that they can start squeezing out everyone else from the hobby entirely. This will work over time.

The reason is friction. If you go with the flow, friction reduces to zero. If you go against it, friction increases well past your Quit Point. The mass audience does not go out of their way for anything; they abhor friction like it was the plague. They will applaud the Walled Garden and be grateful for it; this means they will adopt it and do so with enthusiasm and in great numbers.

WOTC will cease support for Muh Rule Zero within a few years accordingly because Normies Hate Calvinball and Corporate wants Normiebux. This is how WOTC gets their Billion Dollar Annual Revenue Brand for D&D, and boy are the Conventional Play Cultists going to get mad when they get rugpulled.

There is no future for the Cargo Cult. There is only Official D&D, be it Current Edition or Past Edition.

Wednesday, March 11, 2026

The Business: The MMO Guy Gets Why Network Effects Work

Josh Strife Hayes, again, uses World of Warcraft to explain Network Effects in gaming.

Dungeons & Dragons also set an impossible standard for Tabletop.

Yet that standard is what Normies, Casuals, and Tourists expect and demand from all Tabletop products. They expect to be able to go wherever and play The Game--not your game, The Game--and if they can't do that, they quit.

Tabletop, therefore, cannot be a "Thousand True Fans" thing and Wizards of the Coast knows this. That's why their smarter, more successful moves are those that reduce or kill an element of friction keeping those three segments from playing the game (and thus connecting to and engaging with the Network Effect).

Publishers that refuse to acknowledge this are those that fail. Ryan Dancey recognized this, which is why he tried to reduce that friction by introducing the Open Gaming License (reducing/eliminating friction between products). Some of his successors at Wizards of the Coast have tried to do this from other angles--this is why Beyond is now the primary arm of the D&D busienss and not any form of retail; digital Walled Gardens have far less friction than dead tree books and in-person meetups--while others fucked things up.

What Network Effects do is reduce friction in the most fundamental manner: the ability to do the thing at all. The larger the Network, the easier it is to do the thing and the more likely that other friction-reducing powers come to bear to further reduce overall friction inhibiting Doing The Thing. If you play D&D, you are likely to Do The Thing; if you play it properly--i.e. as the #BROSR has described--in a Clubhouse environment that is globally-networked that reduces friction to near-zero; you'd have to play WOW to get a comparable situation.

Just Play D&D.

Thursday, February 19, 2026

The Business: The Hellmouth Fears The Terminator

Last week ByteDance released Seedance 2.0. You can tell how good it really is by the reactions.

That reaction? Telling. Hollywood knows.

You've got people saying "This is crap!"

One: No, it's not. Well over 80% of people watching these things will not notice that this is AI-generated; they will, at most, think of this as a SFX showcase to drum up software sales and business contracts.

Two: This is as bad as it will be. It only gets better from here, and the rumors of v3.0 on Chinese social media state that single-prompts go to 10 minutes at a time in length. Nine of those is a 90 minute movie, which remains the ideal length that exhibitors want for maximum revenue potential

Three: They will not be able to regulate or lawfare the threat away; this is a global issue, so the rules are actually defined by the party that cares least about IP law- and that means Russia, China, Southeast Asia, and the Stans between them. China, in particular, wipes its ass with US and European IP law. They already have no problem with hosting content that violates it; they will be glad to host and stream AI-generated content that does so.

As we are already seeing with prose/comics (an AI-generated LN already won awards) and Tabletop, we shall see with Vidya and film/TV: total disruption of the existing market and social State of Play. Go ahead, go to YouTube; there's a flood of AI-generate Star Wars fanfilm shorts, which will only get longer and better over the next few years, which itslef is a follow-on from (very formulatic) Human Fuck Yeah audiobook channels (increasingly with accompanying illustrations).

"But no one-"

They are already finding audiences and making mad bank, starting with niches where conventions are already so rigid that they might as well be a Madlib template (i.e. ChickSmut of all sorts, LitRPG, etc.) and the workflow already exists to automate the entire process once you tool up the (virtual) factory.

As it is with books, comics, music, and art so it is now coming to video and and software which means Vidya is next.

By 2030 no one will notice the difference, and Normies TODAY already do not care. They say they do; their Revealed Preferences show that they don't.

This is why Hollywood freaked out. They see it and know they can't stop it.

You can adapt or you can get crushed by it.

Tuesday, February 17, 2026

The Business: I Told You They'd Lie About It

To no one's surprise, Wizards of the Coast did what I said they'd do and just lie about their AI usage.

I put in a start point at the segment where they talk about this news article. It ends at 59:00.

Go figure, this came out during a quarterly investor call, and he layered the lies. ("Teans have discretion" my ass.)

As regular readers know, I am not against AI. I am against suck, and the DD crew shows that WOTC's Art Direction sucks by letting through such AI images. You do need to know certain things to make solid images using AI, and you need to know how the tool you're using works to get the best result; LLM-based image generators work best when you prompt on a very simple basis to allow for a lot of variation in interation, controlling only the core elements, and then filtering out until you get what you're after.

I did that as a shitpost.

I put up a few more to show that it's nowhere near as hard as these twats fucking it up make it look. I make images daily, often for illustrating my Substack articles, and just as often to show what the tool can do in the hands of someone that has an idea of what it is and how it works- and what WOTC's Art Directors allow is stuff by people that don't.

The real issue? It doesn't do nearly the damage that detractors think it does. Most people do not notice, do not care, and could not care less. It's Good Enough, and (as Tex said) Good Enough is Perfect.

That, ultimately, is what drove WOTC to flat out lie about AI usage for art; it will also drive WOTC's use of AI for writing copy. The Normies, Casuals, and Tourists (i.e. WOTC's target audience) do not notice, do not care, and could not care less about it; they just want cheap widgets that are Good Enough for them to use in Beyond and enjoy their themepark power fantasies.

You won't win by fighting this. Network Effects won't allow you to. You have to go premium and bespoke, with concommitment increases in price and expectation, to remain relevant going forward; you can't make a better Basic Bitch Shitbox and win, but you can do a White Glove 100% bespoke ultra high-end luxury product and service that targets Whales- this is where the Kickstarter Begger Scene has to go to stay relevant and stave off the inevitable so they have enough time to pivot to one of the viable post-collapse solutions in one piece.

So far, no one in Conventional Play is even trying to make their own Clubhouse. Too bad for them. WOTC won't let them do what they want in its own, and neither will I in mine.

Sunday, February 15, 2026

The Business: Stop Expecting Anything But Vidya To Threaten Current Edition

To you this is crazy talk. To C-Suite at Wizards and Hasbro, this is what they actually compete with.

Short, sweet, and to the point.

The only errors are the presumption of a narrative, rather than the creation of a self-sustaining perpetual virtual world; the tools shown here can do that too, and it is that--not Le Epic Story--that matters.

The other option for agentic AI additions to Beyond is to cut deals with Hytale to incorporate Current Edition (or even Past Editions) to servers. Generate, shape, populate, and run. Play when, how, for how long you like- no need to Schedule Your Fun or other typical Conventional Play dysfunction.

Yeah, this turns the game into a videogame but that's what Hasbro and WOTC wants anyway.

Conventional Play is unsustainable as it is; the collapse is ongoing, and WOTC wants out by going digital- one way or another. This is another route to removing that "must need other players" friction that is required for WOTC to be satisfied, and it can be implemented as soon as C-Suite gives the go-ahead.

For younger folks, this is preferable to being around a table- even a VTT.

Don't be surprised that this, or something like it, becomes where Current Edition goes in the years ahead- and good luck replacing your table losses going forward if that happens and you resist it. You're going to follow, you're going to quit, or you're going to return to the Real Game and seek admission to the Clubhouse.

Thursday, February 12, 2026

The Culture: The Black Lodge Gets It About AI

Black Lodge Games had one of the more sensible takes on AI.

I will not be so kind: it's happening and there's sweet fuck-all you can do about it but adapt.

"I won't buy stuff that uses it."

Yes, you will. There is no incentive to disclose using it other than to flex, so they're just going to do it regardless of what PR says- yes, they can and will lie to your face about it. It's already getting difficult to notice it when done at all competently, and it's only going to get better; soon you won't notice at all if it's outside your area of expertise, and not long thereafter you won't notice within it.

The commercial incentive to use it, to master it, and to apply it wherever it cuts costs far outweigh all the chimping against it can manage. That is why objectors will lose.

You will accept it. Why? Ultimately, because you won't have a choice; the people who produce the things you want to buy are all going to adopt it because if they don't they will lose to those that do and get crushed. At least it won't be like all the restaurants buying from the same supplier (if you ever worked in one, or for a fast food chain, you know).

"I won't use it!"

Yes, you will, or you won't be employable or be viable in business. You will be crushed by those that do EVERY SINGLE TIME! You no longer have to choose between Fast, Cheap, and Good; you can get all three now, and because you can get all you had better deliver all three OR IT'S YOUR ASS!

"But we can-"

There will be no government regulation that matters; those stupid enough to do so will prompt capital flight to those that don't and (say it with me now) end up crushing the stupid governments EVERY SINGLE TIME!

You will buy AI-made things. You will hire AI-provided services. You will use it in your own work, be it as a wagie or hustling for yourself. This is the new normal, and you will adjust or you will be crushed by those that do.

That's how things will work out, as they did last time there was a major shakeup with the widespread adoption of PCs in the office and then the rise of the Internet before that, and anyone that claims otherwise (and appears to be sustaining themselves) is actually getting their money elsewhere and doing this as an expensive hobby to farm clout or status-signal- like all those bookstores that are funded by Daddy's or Hubby's real jobs.

AI threatens only the shit-tier "talents". That so many in Tabletop are shrieking about AI tells you all you need to know about their real worth, and I can't wait for them to all either bend the knee or shut down.

Tuesday, February 3, 2026

The Business: Ashes of Creation's Implosion Shows Network Effects In Action

Over the weekend, Ashes of Creation--the long-developing ArcheAge style MMORPG--collapsed. Lots of videos dropped about it, but only Josh's matters.

This will start unraveling over the rest of this week and information gets checked and either confirmed or denied.

From what's been revealed: Private Equity bought the studio, goat-fucked the former owner and his team, fired everyone in the US, and will relocate to India (because that's what "overseas" means) to do whatever with it (what "finish" means). In practice, this is dead; divest--economically, socially, emotionally--now.

The Steam release was a surprise for the team; they were not told until the last minute. That's the red flag for insiders.

AoC is Kill.

Network Effects spare no one. This is all due to two things: (a) having to compete with World of Warcraft, and (b) developing a game contrary to the Revealed Preferences of the MMORPG Player Network.

AoC did not compete with WOW of 2004. AoC has to compete with WOW as it is here and now. That's a very big wall to climb, and AoC could not climb it. No Kickstarter game, nor any more conventional alternative (e.g. New World, Throne & Liberty), can compete with World of Warcraft now. It has attained the same position in MMORPGs that Dungeons & Dragons has in Tabletop, Magic: The Gathering has in CCGs, and Warhammer in wargaming. These properties reached a point of absolute, utter and PERMANENT dominance in their niches where competition from without their Network Effect is no longer possible AT ALL.

Instead, each of these are now Eternal Kings of their niches such that they are the Kleenex or Xerox of that space. They do not compete with others within their niche; they compete with comparables in other niches (i.e. all of them compete with Fortnite, Roblox, etc.). They have a Containment Option, an Also-Ran to act as Controlled Opposition that keeps players who need a break within the network by shunting them into a Designated Containment Zone.

(Periodic wiping included, though that tends to run on Sith Succession Principles.)

The MMO scene really has room for THREE: WOW (which has its own sub-retention structures within its model), FF14 (faltering hard at the moment; they screwed up bad with Dawntrail thanks to Death Cult sabotage), and Guild Wars 2. Tabletop really only has one--D&D--and only the various clones (including Palladium) is as close as it gets to a Containment Option; all other niches are so small compared to Fantastic Adventure that even the D&D analogs are only known if they have videogame adaptations of note. The lawsuit over Magic will not kill Magic as the King of CCGs- too many users exist now and there is no alternative.

There is no way to compete and win from without. There is also no way to compete and win from a lesser position. You must wield a superior Network Effect to crush a Network Effect.

There is only D&D. There is only WOW. There is only Magic. There is only Warhammer. There is only Windows (sorry Linux and Mac guys; if you really were superior, you'd be the top Network Effect by now). That's where the money is, that's where the users--especially the Normies and their money--are, and that's where the Social Proof lies. You ain't neo-patroning your way out of that like you might with music, books, or comics (and even then you're outside the Normiesphere so you have no cultural impact, so you don't move the needle). EVERYTHING ELSE EITHER CEASES OPERATIONS OR GOES NON-COMMERCIAL.

This is what justifies the Clubhouse as being superiot to the Basement or the Retail Shop for hobbyist organizing; the former is atomized and easily broken by life events and the childish stupidities this hobby is so notorious for that there's a comic about it (Knights of the Dinner Table), and Diamond just killed the latter. Cons are a no-go for all but a few, by percentage. Clubhouses, on the other hands, are a local social institution by and for hobbyists that are non-commercial in nature- and Clubhouses are where the hobby will survive and thrive, not the corporate Walled Gardens, again due to superior Network Effects.

Monday, February 2, 2026

The Business: Hasbro Gets Sued By Shareholders

Pat reports what we want for G-Dubs next.

This is some Mammon Mob fuckery, but it exists because of the damage that the Death Cult did.

I fully expect this suit to fix nothing. There will be a settlement, no blame will be taken, some chairs get shuffled, and--at best--the Death Cultists get purged while the Mammon Mobsters remain and entrench. There just isn't any external party, or collection of parties, other than (maybe) Games Workshop able to apply the leverage required to get any changes worth a damn.

The end result is that Conventional Play just loses differently. The collapse can't be stopped; WOTC can't be killed from inside, and it's going to take more than a shareholder lawsuit against Hasbro to kill it from without, so The Only Game That Matters (and its Network Effect) ain't going anywhere. Get in the Walled Garden, or seek admission to the Clubhouse. Otherwise all you're going to do is quit by 2030 because Conventional Play won't be able to justify itself; those left will lose to superior media that does Conventional Play better.

Sunday, February 1, 2026

The Business: Vidya Bosses Cutting Dead Weight Is Good

Vidya's shedding dead weight. Death Cultists mad.

There are consequences to turning a popular entertainment medium into an obvious propaganda front.

The usual retort is that these Commies have ties to the Money Printer, but that just got shut off.

The result is that the Usual Suspects have to actually generate profit now to stay afloat, which runs right into Death Cult dogma and runs it over with the certainly of an avalanche. These people in C-Suite, caught between the Death Cult and the Mammon Mob, are forced to side with the latter to save their own asses and that's what was done. Alas, the Death Culists within did not go quietly; they leaked like a siv to their Fellow Travelers in the media, which is why the scandals kept getting out.

Yes, this is Red On Red violence.

We'll see this again with tomorrow's post, where it's already gone from slinging hitpieces to lawsuits.

Thursday, January 22, 2026

The Culture: I Told You The Future Was One-Man Bands

My friend Oliver Campbell has opened a storefront for his art. It's called "The Digital Noosphere" and you can find it here.

The Noosphere: the "sphere of human thought," representing a stage of evolutionary development where collective human consciousness and mental activity become a dominant influence on the Earth.

This place, the Digital Noosphere, combines our creative human minds with generative AI tools, and the necessary delicate human touch that sparks life into art, helping us stay connected and be human.

Stay and explore, and find something you enjoy. Buy with confidence; all of the works here are extremely high quality, and unrivaled.

It's an art store. Oliver makes his own images to Print On Demand. He takes commissions and he'll frame things for you, even if it's not currently listed; if you want something Just For You, ask him. I suggested the Aviator pic you see below, and as soon as I can spare the cash I'm buying the framed version.

Examples:



You want to know how he does it? Talk to him. See those socials on the main page? Check them. He is one man, using the tools now at his disposal, to use his acumen as an artist to create works of quality with such alacrity that it is astounding. This is stuff that would otherwise take weeks or more to produce, and he can do it in minutes--I've seen him do it; that's how the Avaviator got made--and he's already fulfilling orders- including one to Finland and one to Japan, so far.

The best part? There is nothing he's doing that you can't. He'll talk about that too if you ask him.

Like something? Buy it. Want something? Ask him. This isn't the old days; you don't have to chose between fast, good, or cheap now. You can get all three.

Tuesday, January 20, 2026

The Culture: We're Getting Real Close To The Clubhouse Breaking Containment

The Professor tries to give good news.

Dump the storefront and focus on providing the secure Third Space. That's where the money is now.

He's so close to a proper Clubhouse. All he really need is to do the CostCo thing: charge membership fees (to price out low rents, culling 80% of his problems right there), and as a perk members can ship orders of gaming stuff to the Clubhouse for pickup. He doesn't need to stock a damned thing, and only needs to have some space set aside to hold packages, but I don't think he's ready for that leap just yet. He will once he runs the numbers.

This is where the money will be going forward. Less Endless Product Slop. More Secure Playspace Locations. Member-supported Third Spaces with curated and vetted membership rosters are where things have to go, so it is going to be the case that those willing to make it a premium will be able to charge a premium price for it.

Saturday, January 17, 2026

The Business: The Future Is One-Man Bands

Tabletop Publishers are going to shit themselves.

Couple this with the tutorials that my pal Oliver Campbell does on Twitter for image generation in Grok.

I just threw this together quick to show (a) how fast this can be done, and (b) you can break the frame and add art style direction without any difficulty. This is scuffed (needs revision) but you see how easy it is to do this with Grok now. Illustrations are now doable entirely on your own if you can properly describe what you want to see.

This is why I am confident that I can deliver BRODUM as a solo project and still show-up a lot of established publishers all while spending nothing but time.

I'll look into Cowork; if that can further boost my output by reducing elimninating the time spent on bitchwork then I'll adopt it.

We are moving away from the value-add skillset being the gruntwork; we are moving towards the value-add being the Command Level skills, of project management and oversight- of being the Master managing and overseeing a team of appentices and assistants. The days of needing lots of human labor to design, publish, and promote Tabletop product (or any similar product; you better believe card games, board games, novels, comics, film/TV, and videogames will be similarly affected) is going to fade away over the next several years as this potential is recognized and realized- with the seismic shift in the economy and society that will come with that shift.

Wednesday, December 17, 2025

The Business: Cargo Cult Confirmed Crashing

We have it from the horse's mouth.

Fuck all of you Conventional Play Cargo Cultists. Take the hint and shut down with what grace you can manage.

If you persist despite several Black Swan events combining to make your business model impossible to continue, you deserve to lose everything when bankruptcy comes to you in turn. You can't keep rolling crowdfunding campaigns over to keep the doors open indefinitely, especially as many of you suck at business.

Your counterparts in Vidya can't be that stupid--and they just got goat-fucked by their own version of Diamond collapsing--so take the hint and quit.

Your sales channel just died. Your retail outlets are going to follow. Your entire business model cannot continue; the very thing I said was going to happen to you is now happening and--because none of you bothered to listen--you're in the exact place I told you that you'd be if you didn't leap to Vidya or quit being a commercial operation.

I TOLD YOU SO! YOU DIDN'T LISTEN! NOW YOU'RE SCREWED! FUCK YOU AND DIE!

The fireworks are rather lovely behind the iron gates of the Clubhouse, where I can just watch it all unfold and laugh as you.