The Culture: This Man Proved That "Fantasy" & "Science Fiction" Are Fake Genres

This guy didn't realize it, but he proved that "Fantasy" and "Science Fiction" ARE FAKE GENRES!

TLDR: All that changes are the trappings and the setting. The narrative structure is IDENTICAL so they play out EXACTLY THE SAME WAY!

This is why Andre Norton and Leigh Brackett can write "science fiction" that is really "fantasy" with a bare whiff of justification for the tale's telling: they are both doing Fantastic Adventure fiction, same as Burroughs, Meritt, Moorcock, Howard, Smith, and everyone else in Appendix N.

It's also why Shadowrun is just D&D With Chrome & Guns; changing the trappings and the setting didn't change the substance of gameplay one damned bit.

Dune (and its knockoffs, 40K and Fading Suns) is just a resetting of The Sabers of Paradise (go look that one up).

Star Wars (the original) is The Hidden Fortress plus The Dambusters.

Never, ever mistake a Product Category for a Genre; the former is a Brand Name thing, while the latter is all about narrative structure- seeming vs. substance.

"Fantasy" does not exist. "Science Fiction" does not exist. There are other fake genres; they also do not exist.

The Culture: Roll For Combat Can't Fix Itself

Steer clear. They're going to crater.

First, and foremost, they immediately went all Muh Relativisismsmsmsmsms and Muh Graygoo Morality. That alone makes them incapable of surviving the changes that are upon the hobby; it demonstrates such a degree of intellectual capture that they get rendered fragile due to inability to pivot as required to conform themselves to the environment that they are now in.

But the real killer? Despite being plugged into the discourse, they again show the meme is true.

They maintain the Cargo Cult Just So Cult Non-Game priors. This is why they hold that wrong opinion.

They cannot conceive of proper play, and recoil like vampires confronted with the Cross when they do encounter it, so they expose their capture into this small-minded thinking by their reaction.

They can't adapt. They won't adapt. Therefore they will be crushed as the ground shifts out from under their feet and the weight of Wizards of the Coast's Walled Garden crushes them from above while the #BROSR cuts off their retreat from below, trapping them in the middle where they get squished and killed as a direct consequence of their own willful and proud ignorance of how this hobby really works- the fate these Endless Product Slop merchants deserve.

The Business: You Can't Run From Your Fuckups Anymore

On Thursday of last week, Black Lodge Games cut this video on RuneQuest.

Ars Magica got this right.

The trick is to design the rules of the game to be the reality of the world and then present those rules in the manner that your man would comprehend them in situ. Runequest somehow fucked up what Pendragon/Paladin/Prince Valiant and Stormbringer/Elric! as well as Call of Cthulhu got right.

Doing this is how you ensure that, no matter who picks up the manual, they operate the machine the same way (so long as they actually follow directions). What has gone on instead is what too many Official Setting projects do: become Setting Bibles for Intellectual Property development.

Furthermore we see that these guys became lorenerds for their own creation. No one fucking cares about your fucking lore. Players need to know the stuff that matters to play here and now; if it does not directly and immediately matter to play, it is irrelevant and should be discarded. If rolling a man looks like it involves doing homework, you fucked up and you deserve to fail.

This is what Ars did, across its editions, which is why it still gets played by its cult-like and cult-sized following. You don't need to know shit about Europe in the Middle-Ages; you need only to know what your man's specific situation is, and how he relates to everyone around him. Everything else can be done as you go. Hell, even the "Hermetic Magic" is made-up bullshit (vs. IRL Hermetic Magic).

AM is what Steve here wants RQ to be.

This why RQ is on borrowed time; its fuckups are catching up to it, and to Chaosium, which threatens both game and publisher in ways unique to them unless and until they correct course and put out the proper products that people have consistently revealed--there's that Revealed Preference thing again--that they want.

Dry academic bullshit ain't it, chief.

The Culture: Yes, Twitter Now Is Far Better Than It Was And The Enemy Hates It

In the larger discourse, there is good news; this came out on Monday this past week.

This is not necessarily across the board, and Elon's people don't necessarily adhere to his Free Speech dogma; he too has Stay Behinds to flush out.

Take the W, folks. Twitter is still better than it was before Elon bought it and began his purges and reconfigurations, and it continues to improve. Everyone wants to be there as it is the place to be; it has the Network Effect. With still more improvements to come, it will only get better.

The Culture: The Soup Aisle Sucked Vs. Boardgames Too

Boardgame alternatives to the Cargo Cult have also been around for decades and were also a better option.

Same thing: play when I want, how I want, for as long as I want with no ongoing commitments. No bullshit rules fuckery.

This isn't as good a value proposition as the Vidya comparison, but it is still far superior for fulfilling the Cargo Cult Game paradigm of play than what they insist Tabletop has to be about.

Oh, and it's cheaper overall because edition changes are few (if ever) and definitely far between. I can also include Talisman, Advanced Heroquest, Runequest and a lot more than that- and if Sword World does well enough in translation there may be PDFs made available of those Japanese boardgame counterparts also.

Tabletop is not boardgaming or cardgaming. It is not Vidya. It is something separate, distinct, and apart from all of them- which means it is not as the Cargo Cult insists it is either.

It's Braunstein, and that demands something very different- and very human.

The Culture: The Soup Aisle Sucked Vs. Vidya Since 1980

When I said that the Soup Aisle's cult game got rooked by Vidya decades ago, I was not kidding.

I'm stopping just shy of the SSI Gold Box Games, where TSR proved that its own IP does better in Vidya in the Cult Game format.

Play when you want, how you want, for as long as you want, with a Referee that won't LOLSORANDOM the rules Because (Bullshit) Reasons. That's across-the-board superior to what the Soup Aisle in their Just So Cult Game claims is how the hobby works.

Almost all of them are now available on Steam and GOG for dirt-cheap prices, even less when on sale. Why put up with Knights of the Dinner Table bullshit when this is cheaper, easier, more convenient, and has superior gameplay experiences?

This is why the Cargo Cult is cooked; they can't beat this, they never have, and they never will.

The Culture: Towards A Corpo And Merchant-Free Hobby

I regularly post Razorfist's video about how BattleTech is really held and controlled by the fans- not the corpos.

I posit that this is also viable for Uncle George's Space Opera. Use the old West End Game if you want something instantly familiar and usable, but that's not the only option; the reason is that what you really want is a game where the capacity to translate from either IRL or Approved Lore measurements to game terms and back is trivially easy to do by the hobbyist.

Why? Because a fan-controlled Star Wars is one where fan channels who actually get the IP and can contrbute to it competenly and effectively are going to be where you go to find things to include that the Enemy never would- for example:

The Devil Mouse would never go for that.

This is the flip-side of the mass proliferation of digital content generation tools and distribution channels. Can you produce Endless Product Slop? Sure. You can also know where the human touch matters more, and use those same tools to clear away the bitchwork so that you can focus time and attention on what you specifically add to the overal result.

We don't need corpos or merchants selling us what our stories are anymore. We need to know how to seize, hold, and use these tools instead. Fuck Muh Commercial Viability; if this means it's only done by hobbyists for hobbyists because you can't make a living at it, that's a net improvement as it culls the disinterested grifters from the space.