Sunday, November 22, 2026

The Business: The Man Who Gets Network Effects Wins

Robert's heart is in the right place, but any such effort is doomed to fail.

The reason, as it is in Tabletop and MMOs, is NETWORK EFFECTS!

The tell is in the intent to build something in mass media that demands the capacity to capture and hold a critical mass of the population in terms of attention in order to deliver products and services to them. Bitch you ain't going to beat Amazon, YouTube, or Netflix at their own game.

Ryan Dancey explained what actually happens to would-be rivals: they end up feeding their purported enemy. This was in 1999, and time proved him right. Attend!

Here's the logic in a nutshell. We've got a theory that says that D&D is the most popular role playing game because it is the game more people know how to play than any other game. (For those of you interested researching the theory, this concept is called "The Theory of Network Externalities").

Note: This is a very painful concept for a lot of people to embrace, including a lot of our own staff, and including myself for many years. The idea that D&D is somehow "better" than the competition is a powerful and entrenched concept. The idea that D&D can be "beaten" by a game that is "better" than D&D is at the heart of every business plan from every company that goes into marketplace battle with the D&D game. If you accept the Theory of Network Externalities, you have to admit that the battle is lost before it begins, because the value doesn't reside in the game itself, but in the network of people who know how to play it.

If you accept (as I have finally come to do) that the theory is valid, then the logical conclusion is that the larger the number of people who play D&D, the harder it is for competitive games to succeed, and the longer people will stay active gamers, and the more value the network of D&D players will have to Wizards of the Coast.

In fact, we believe that there may be a secondary market force we jokingly call "The Skaff Effect", after our own Skaff Elias. Skaff is one of the smartest guys in the company, and after looking at lots of trends and thinking about our business over a long period of time, he enunciated his theory thusly: "All marketing and sales activity in a hobby gaming genre eventually contributes to the overall success of the market share leader in that genre."

In other words, the more money other companies spend on their games, the more D&D sales are eventually made. Now, there are clearly issues of efficiency - not every dollar input to the market results in a dollar output in D&D sales; and there is a substantial time lag between input and output; and a certain amount of people are diverted from D&D to other games never to return. However, we believe very strongly that the net effect of the competition in the RPG genre is positive for D&D.

Robert's proposal would only serve to reinforce the very hegemony he seeks to shatter by inviting comparisons that never go in his favor. You do not win by doing this.

There is someone that does comprehend Network Effects and knows how to play them to his advantage: Vox Day.

Recently he launched Castalia Unlimited, the ebook platform for his publishing company. Why did he do this? To take advantage of Amazon's mistaken use of the power over the friction in the network that they dominate. The mistake was in disabling user control over Kindle ebooks and readers; Vox decided to exploit that mistake to carve out a niche where he can invite favorable comparison- to fight and win. He further added to it by focusing on books that are not widely available to Anglophone readers, which will draw yet more attention, and the pricing is a steal; I don't know the numbers, but I can guess that he'll be fine if he can get about 1000 subscribers.

That's how you fight and win when you contend with a Network Effect that you don't control. Amazon has no counter to this, not at this time, because it cannot commit to any state of mind that admits its own errors allowed Vox (and others who also followed that lead) to do what he did. CU (et. al.) could be wiped out overnight if they just undid the mistake that made it possible, but until they do this will continue succeed.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Anonymous comments are banned. Pick a name, and "Unknown" (et. al.) doesn't count.